Le faux binaire d’Haïti : pourquoi le fétichisme chromatique déforme le passé national — et bloque l’avenir
Haiti’s False Binary: Why Color Fetishism Distorts a Nation’s Past—and Blocks Its Future By Patrick Prézeau Stephenson * PORT-AU-PRINCE — In “Face à l’Histoire… Duvaliérisme vs Aristidisme,” J.L.T. reprises a familiar drama in Haitian political discourse: a mythic clash between two so-called titanic ideologies—Duvaliérisme and Aristidisme—cast as the determinative poles of national history. It is a rhetorically charged narrative, seductively moral, almost theatrical. It is also a conceptual dead end [1]. The framing reduces Haiti’s political evolution to a chromatic psychodrama: black middle-class nationalism versus mulatto elite exclusion, followed later by a populist priest’s messianic rise. That interpretive habit—what we might call colorist historiography —has become a fetish. It substitutes symbolic antagonisms for structural analysis, emotional archetypes for economic realities. And it persists not because it illuminates, but because it is narratively convenient. It f...