How can France Honor its Debt to Haiti?

 

How can France Honor its Debt to Haiti?

Patrick Prézeau Stephenson et al., Collectif du Manifeste L'Appel du Lambi.

September 2023

 

The ransom demanded by France following the Haitian revolution of 1804, which resulted in Haiti's independence, has weighed heavily on the shoulders of the young Haitian nation for two centuries. The exorbitant sum of 150 million gold francs (300% of its GDP), equivalent to about $30 billion in 2000 and more than $80 billion in 2023, has been a crushing economic burden. This article explores how France can begin a new era of cooperation with Haiti by honoring its historic debt.

The Recognition of the "Ransom of Independence"

In 2015, former French President François Hollande recognized these payments as the "ransom of independence." However, this recognition has not been followed by tangible actions to repay this historic debt. The French government of the time quickly reclassified this debt as moral rather than financial. Yet Haiti's debt to France, resulting from this ransom, has persisted in various forms, limiting the country's economic and social development.

A New Era of Cooperation

It is time to consider modern diplomacy based on open dialogue and mutual respect. France, recognizing its moral debt to Haiti, should be ready to explore all possibilities of partnership for the economic and social development of the country.

1. Cooperation in Key Sectors

By focusing efforts on the crucial sectors of health and education, France could make a significant contribution to improving the quality of life of the Haitian population. Cooperation agreements could be concluded, such as training Haitian teachers to ensure better quality education.

2. Strengthening Cultural Ties

Haiti and France share a common culture and history, ties that need to be strengthened and deepened. The organization of events such as the "Year of Haiti in France" and the "Year of France Haiti" would promote cultural, tourism and economic exchanges between the two countries. This could mark the beginning of a new era of special bilateral relations.

Adapting Foreign Policy

It is essential for Haiti to continue to assess and adapt its foreign policy to meet the changing needs of the nation. By looking for innovative ways to strengthen health and education efforts for younger generations, the country can move towards a brighter future.

In conclusion, France has a unique opportunity to correct the mistakes of the past and honor its debt to Haiti. By engaging in mutually beneficial cooperation and contributing to Haiti's development, France can help build a brighter future for the Haitian nation and strengthen ties between the two countries.

The amount of cooperation between France and Haiti could vary depending on the specific agreements concluded between the two countries. Here are some areas where financial cooperation could be considered, although the precise amounts would require further negotiations. It is our responsibility to deepen and justify a proposal for international cooperation between Haiti and France that is balanced, beneficial and achievable for both parties. Here is an expansion and justification for the estimated annual cooperation between $1.05 billion and $2.82 billion, taking into account the financial capacity of France and the needs of Haiti:

• France Economic Context: France is one of the most advanced economies in the world, with a GDP of $2,782.91 billion in 2022. As a prosperous nation, it has the financial capacity to contribute significantly to Haiti's development efforts. This cooperation can be seen as an act of solidarity with a country that has struggled for its independence.
• Moral and Historical Debt: The sum of 150 million gold francs imposed on Haiti in exchange for its recognition of independence is widely recognized as a moral debt of France to Haiti. Therefore, it is appropriate for France to contribute substantially to the reconstruction and development of Haiti to compensate for this historical legacy.
• Haiti's Critical Needs: Haiti faces many challenges, including poverty, lack of access to quality education and health care, food insecurity, and underdeveloped infrastructure. Substantial funding is needed to address these issues and improve the quality of life of the Haitian people.
•  Sustainable Development Goals: The United Nations has defined Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to eradicate poverty, promote education and improve health in developing countries. France, as a member of the United Nations, has a role to play in achieving these goals, especially in the context of a historically linked nation like Haiti.
• Bilateral Cooperation: Increased cooperation between France and Haiti can strengthen diplomatic, cultural, and economic ties between the two countries. By investing significantly in Haiti, France can contribute to regional stability and the promotion of democracy and human rights in the region.
• Flexibility and Adaptability: The range of $1.05 billion to $2.82 billion per year allows for flexibility to respond to Haiti's changing needs and the changing priorities of both countries. It also reflects the fact that France may choose to invest in various areas such as education, health, infrastructure, and economic development.

In short, the estimate of this annual financial cooperation is justifiable in view of the financial capacities of France, its shared history with Haiti, and Haiti's critical needs. This would be a significant gesture of solidarity and international cooperation for Haiti's development and stability while strengthening relations between the two nations.

• Top of form

 

Scenario 1 (Blue Curve): Haïti's financial roadmap begins with an annual repayment of $1.05 billion. With each payment, we watch as the debt gradually diminishes over 50 equal installments.  

Scenario 2 (Red Curve): In an alternate scenario, the annual repayment of $2.82 billion signifies an even more accelerated path to debt redemption.  

The Message: Both curves, while different in pace, share a common destination: the complete payment of Haïti's debt after 50 installments. They convey a powerful message of restorative justice, international collaboration, and a renewed sense of hope for Haïti.

Beyond the Data: This visual narrative is not just about numbers; it's about the potential for transformative change. It invites us to reflect on the historical and moral dimensions of international relations and to consider how cooperation can reshape the destiny of nations.

As we admire this graph, let us not only appreciate its aesthetics but also its significance in inspiring discussions on debt relief, cooperation, and the enduring pursuit of justice. It reminds us that a better world is possible when nations come together to right historical wrongs and build a brighter future for all.